The Black Hole
40 AD to 600 AD and Qur’an 61:14
A Fatal Historical Contradiction
Islam’s claim to prophetic continuity includes a bold Qur’anic assertion in Surah 61:14:
"O you who have believed, be supporters of Allah, as when Jesus, the son of Mary, said to the disciples, ‘Who are my supporters for Allah?’ The disciples said, ‘We are supporters of Allah.’ And a faction of the Children of Israel believed and a faction disbelieved. So We supported those who believed against their enemy, and they became dominant." (Q 61:14)
What Does Surah 61:14 Claim?
-
Jesus called on his disciples to be “supporters of Allah” (i.e., true believers in monotheism)
-
Among the Children of Israel, some believed and some rejected
-
God supported those who believed and made them “dominant”
The Qur’anic Narrative Implies:
-
Early Christianity had a group of faithful “supporters of Allah” aligned with true monotheism.
-
This faithful faction was divinely supported and rose to prominence.
-
This lineage of true believers is the precursor to Islam, which claims to restore and continue their pure message.
The Fatal Historical Gap
If this claim is true, we should expect:
-
A continuous historical community from Jesus through the centuries up to Muhammad, faithful to the pure monotheism Jesus preached.
-
Records of such believers surviving and transmitting their faith.
-
Historical dominance or at least visible influence of these “supporters of Allah” (i.e., proto-Muslims or true monotheists) after Jesus and before Muhammad.
But What Does History Show?
-
No historical evidence of such a continuous faithful community.
The early followers of Jesus became Christianity, which developed doctrines (Trinity, divinity of Christ) explicitly rejected by Islam. -
The Children of Israel (Jews) did not embrace Jesus as Messiah or monotheism in Islamic terms.
Jewish history from 40–600 AD shows no record of mass conversions to Islam or “supporters of Allah” as defined by the Qur’an. -
Christianity grew dominant, but its theology contradicts the Islamic portrayal of Jesus’ message.
The Trinity and the divinity of Jesus became core Christian doctrines, which Islam vehemently opposes. -
There is no record of a faction of Israelites or Christians living with Islamic monotheism, let alone dominating their enemies during this period.
Why This is a Fatal Contradiction
-
Surah 61:14 implicitly confirms continuity of true monotheism after Jesus.
-
The historical record shows discontinuity — no followers of “Jesus as a Muslim” exist before Muhammad.
-
The Qur’an does not acknowledge a break or gap; it claims divine support and victory for believers continuously.
-
But historically, there was no victorious faction faithful to this message for 600 years.
Theological Implications
Islam’s claim to prophetic continuity depends heavily on the premise that true monotheism, as taught by Jesus and his disciples, persisted and flourished in some form.
Surah 61:14 is a key verse that enforces this claim.
The 560-year black hole between Jesus and Muhammad:
-
Directly contradicts the claim that true believers (supporters of Allah) remained dominant or even visible.
-
Exposes a historical silence that cannot be explained by divine support or prophecy.
-
Implies Islam is a new religious invention, not a continuation.
Summary
| Qur’anic Claim (61:14) | Historical Reality |
|---|---|
| Jesus’ supporters remained faithful and dominant | No such group existed post-Jesus in historical records |
| True monotheism persisted visibly | Christianity and Judaism contradict Islamic monotheism |
| Divine support guaranteed victory | 600 years of religious fragmentation and polytheism in Arabia |
This verse, rather than affirming Islamic continuity, highlights the contradiction that arises when comparing Islamic claims with historical facts.
No comments:
Post a Comment